In 2010, Universal aimed to resurrect a classic monster with modern visual effects and a star-studded cast, not to mention having legendary make-up artist Rick Baker on hand, but the result was a moody, occasionally stunning film that struggled under the weight of its ambition. Let’s journey back in time and enter the foggy moors and see what happened.
Set in the fog-drenched moors of Victorian England, our story begins with Lawrence Talbot (Benicio Del Toro), a brooding actor with a penchant for tragic stares. After a lifetime of avoiding his creepy family estate, Blackmoor, he’s lured back by the mysterious death of his brother, Ben. Turns out Ben was mauled to pieces under mysterious circumstances. (Hint: It’s not a bear.) Ben’s grieving fiancée, Gwen Conliffe (Emily Blunt), convinces Lawrence to stay and investigate, because who better to solve a gruesome murder mystery than a Shakespearean actor with daddy issues?
“Couldn’t we get someone to call Hercule Poirot?”
Upon arriving at Blackmoor, Lawrence reunites with his estranged father, Sir John Talbot (Anthony Hopkins). Sir John is a strange, wild-eyed man who seems a little too comfortable with the ominous howls echoing through the night. He claims he’s locked the family’s past behind a thick layer of eccentricity, cryptic warnings, and an alarming number of animal skulls. Nothing suspicious here, right? While snooping around for answers, Lawrence stumbles into a local tavern and learns that Blackmoor has a reputation for werewolf attacks, a fun local legend that everyone treats as fact. The villagers’ advice? Don’t go into the woods. His father also recommends staying inside during the full moon, So, naturally, Lawrence ignores all that advice and while investigating a gypsy encampment, things go from bad to worse.
Mind you, a lot worse for others.
While tracking the beast through the fog, Lawrence is bitten during a particularly gruesome encounter and is only saved by the timely arrival of some gun-toting locals. Despite his serious wounds he somehow survives (thanks to the not-so-tender ministrations from the gypsies), but he’s not quite the same afterwards. Not only does he rapidly heal, but his senses have sharpened, his strength increases, and he develops an unhealthy love for moonbathing. The local villagers, led by the determined Inspector Aberline (Hugo Weaving), start to piece together the connection between Lawrence’s newfound glow-up and the violent attacks happening around Blackmoor. Unfortunately, a posse and a passel of silver bullets aren’t enough to stop this “new and improved” Lawrence Talbot.
Cue a dark and bloody night.
Things get even more complicated when Sir John drops a bombshell: not only is Lawrence turning into a werewolf, but lycanthropy runs in the family. Yep, dear old dad has been rocking the werewolf curse for years and is surprisingly nonchalant about it. In fact, he kind of enjoys it. Cue a father-son bonding moment in which Sir John explains the joys of werewolfing out while ominously sharpening his claws. The film culminates in an epic werewolf-on-werewolf battle as Lawrence and Sir John face off in the ruins of their ancestral home. Think of it as family therapy but with more growling, slashing, and roaring fires. Meanwhile, Gwen must decide if her love for Lawrence is strong enough to handle his other half or if she should consider putting him down with a silver bullet—a tough decision when your boyfriend keeps eating your neighbours.
“So, he’s a dog.”
Stray Observation:
• People who walk through dark and spooky forests and call out “Show yourself!” are just asking to be attacked by a werewolf. Darwinism in action.
• That Lon Chaney Jr. was supposed to be the son of Claude Rains in the 1941’s The Wolf Man was always a bit of a stretch, a tradition this sequel continues with Benicio Del Toro playing the son of Anthony Hopkins.
•
Lawrence meets a man with a silver wolf-headed cane that he acquired in
the Village of Gévaudan, France, which makes this a reference to both
the original film and Brotherhood of the Wolf.
•
That Inspector Aberline would immediately suspect Lawrence is
ridiculous. He wasn’t around when his brother was killed, and several
locals witnessed the “creature” attack him. No wonder he wasn’t able to
catch Jack the Ripper, as he’s clearly a terrible investigator.
• No
matter what Lawrence was wearing previously, the Wolfman is always in
the same clothes post-transformation, which was the case in the 1941
original as well.
• Our tragic hero had spent most of his life in America, only to come to London and become a werewolf. You could almost say, “He’s an American Werewolf in London.”
•
Lawrence stays alive long enough to thank Gwen for shooting him and
reassures her that it was the right thing to do, similar to the ending
of Werewolf of London (1935).
This movie takes stalking quite literally.
When Universal Pictures greenlit 2010’s The Wolfman, the vision was clear: resurrect a classic monster for a modern audience, blending the gothic elegance of the 1941 original with contemporary filmmaking techniques. What unfolded instead was a textbook example of how not to approach a remake. This had all the makings of a modern horror classic: a rich legacy to draw from, an A-list cast, a celebrated director in Joe Johnston, and an Oscar-winning makeup effects artist in Rick Baker. Yet, despite its potential, the film stumbles, burdened by a clunky script, uneven performances, and a tonal identity crisis that leaves it howling in frustration rather than triumph. The cast, while impressive on paper, delivers mixed performances. Del Toro captures the torment of Lawrence’s curse but often feels too subdued, as if sleepwalking through his role. Hopkins, on the other hand, gleefully chews the scenery, teetering on the edge of camp. Blunt is underutilized, her character relegated to the familiar “tragic love interest” archetype, while Weaving’s Aberline brings a welcome dose of sharpness and determination.
“Why, Mr. Talbot? Why, why? Why do you do it?”
One area where The Wolfman earns praise is its visual design. The Victorian-era setting is beautifully realized, with shadow-drenched forests, foggy moors, and grand but decaying mansions providing a suitably eerie backdrop. The set design and cinematography transport the viewer to Victorian England, drenched in eerie fog and moonlight. If this remake succeeded in any area, it was in its visual presentation. The production design, cinematography, and Danny Elfman’s haunting score created a rich gothic atmosphere. The Victorian-era setting, with its shadowy forests and crumbling mansions, was a feast for the eyes. However, these aesthetic triumphs were not enough to compensate for the film’s narrative and tonal shortcomings.
It does have some nice cinematic werewolf moments.
Sadly, a defining feature of The Wolfman is its heavy use of CGI, particularly in the transformation sequences and action scenes. While Rick Baker’s practical effects work—most notably in the werewolf makeup—was superb, the film undermined this craftsmanship by overlaying it with excessive computer-generated imagery. The werewolf transformations, a hallmark of the genre, felt sterile and unconvincing due to the CGI’s weightlessness. Unlike the visceral, painful transformations seen in classics like An American Werewolf in London, this movie’s digital approach failed to evoke the same sense of awe or horror. Similarly, the action scenes, such as the climactic battle between Lawrence and Sir John, were marred by cartoonish effects that broke the immersion.
When werewolves go bad.
In conclusion, Joe Johnston’s The Wolfman is a missed opportunity—a film with the potential to rejuvenate a beloved monster mythos but one that falters under the weight of its ambitions. While it boasts some striking visuals and moments of genuine horror, it ultimately succumbs to uneven storytelling, misaligned performances, and an over-reliance on CGI. What should have been a modern Gothic masterpiece instead feels like a beautiful but hollow shell.