In my ongoing series of reviews on adaptations of Richard Connell’s short “The Most Dangerous Game,” there have been many interesting takes on his short story but today we will look at one of the more bizarre versions, where a hunter will attempt to bring down what most would consider “The Least Dangerous Game.”
Created by legendary television producer Sherwood Schwartz, Gilligan’s Island was a CBS sitcom that ran for three seasons, and dealt with seven castaways being shipwrecked on an uncharted island somewhere in the Pacific Ocean. The series had a fairly consistent formula, which consisted mostly of various attempts to get off the island being thwarted by the bumbling and hapless first mate, Gilligan (Bob Denver), much to the chagrin of his fellow castaways. Another key element to this series was the various visitors to the island, so many that one couldn’t help but wonder at the remarkable regularity and assortment of people who would find this uncharted island, all of whom either refuse or fail to help rescue the castaways.
“Skipper, are we that unlikable?”
What makes “The Hunter” stand out is how dark it is. There are no jungle boys or lost pilots to give our castaways hope, in this episode a man arrives on the island who decides to hunt and murder Gilligan. Not your typical sitcom fair. The plot kicks off when Gilligan spots a helicopter landing in the lagoon, sensing rescue is imminent he runs to tell his fellow castaways. Unfortunately, this helicopter is carrying a hunter named Jonathan Kincaid (Rory Calhoun) and his Asian manservant Ramoo (Harold Sakata). Kincaid is looking for game to hunt on the island but when he learns that there’s no game on this particular island he decides on a different sort of prey. When he realizes that no one knows of these castaways he confides in his servant that while there’s no game of the 4-legged kind on this island “I’ve always wondered what it be like to hunt the most dangerous game of all. Man.”
“If this works out, I could get my villain union card.”
Needless to say, the castaways are a bit distressed at this news. But who will he hunt? Looking over them, he decides that the Howells (Jim Backus and Natalie Schafer) wouldn’t give him much of a challenge and that the Skipper (Alan Hale Jr.) is too big a target while the Professor (Russell Johnson) would be too easy due to the belief that he’d over think things. Ginger (Tina Louise) and Mary Ann (Dawn Wells) are equally unfit for the hunt, commenting to Mary Ann “My dear, shooting you would be like shooting an Easter bunny.” So, by process of elimination, Gilligan is the only worthy choice. He informs the castaways that he will give Gilligan twenty-four hours to elude him, promising to rescue the crew and passengers of the S.S. Minnow, that is if Gilligan succeeds. Why the castaways believe this for a second is the true mystery here.
“What, don’t I look trustworthy?”
Stray Observations:
- Two years earlier the series Wild Wild West had done their own take on “The Most Dangerous Game” called “Night of the Sudden Death” and it was filmed mostly on the Gilligan’s Island lagoon set.
- Gilligan has a brief exchange with a North American brown owl but that species of owl wouldn’t be living on a South Pacific Island. Was it a castaway as well?
- You would think an experienced hunter like Kincaid would know there is no natural way for big game to be on this small uncharted island
- The helicopter Kincaid arrives in is a Bell 47 and as this island is said to be 250 miles south of Hawaii it’s hard to believe that a helicopter with a range of 245 miles would have safely reached our castaways.
- Gilligan is being hunted through the jungle but never considers the fact that his trademark red shirt and white hat don’t exactly provide the best camouflage.
- Gilligan has a brief exchange with a North American brown owl but that species of owl wouldn’t be living on a South Pacific Island. Was it a castaway as well?
- Bond fans may recognize Harold Sakata as he is best known as the villainous henchman Oddjob in the James Bond movie Goldfinger.
- The Professor is supposed to be the smart one in our group but he never thinks to tamper with the helicopter to keep Kincaid from leaving without them.
This is a guy who couldn’t turn a radio into a simple transmitter.
As stated, this is a surprisingly dark episode of Gilligan’s Island and is easily one of the most serious and suspenseful episodes of the entire series. Of course, as an adaptation of “The Most Dangerous Game”
it pretty much had to have that darker element – the hunting and
murdering of a person is pretty grim no matter how you look at it – but
as this was a family sitcom of the 1960s there is a lot of comedy tossed
in to lighten the mood. I particularly liked the exchange between Mr.
Howell and Kincaid where the hunter is trying to determine if Thurston
Howell the Third would be worthy prey.
Jonathan Kincaid – “Are you a hunter, Mr. Howell?”
Mr. Howell – “Uh, yeah, but I went on a tiger hunt, and I shot three of the terrible beasts in fifteen minutes.”
Kincaid – “Three in fifteen minutes, you must have been pleased.”
Mr. Howell – “Yes, but the directors of the zoo were furious!”
Jim Backus is a National Treasure.
That said, there are some questionable plot elements in “The Hunter” such as seven people not once trying to overpower these two interlopers, and sure, Oddjob is a formidable adversary and Kincaid has a gun but even Mrs. Howell was able to outmanoeuvre the manservant, and the Skipper and the Professor both had an opportunity to rest the gun away from Kincaid. I’m not asking for these guys to turn into Jean-Claude Van Damme but is putting in a little effort to save their Little Buddy too much to ask? There’s even a scene where Kincaid falls into a water trough and his gun is rendered useless but no one thinks this would be a good opportunity to act.
This is just embarrassing.
In conclusion, this is a very good episode of Gilligan’s Island and while it does have some dubious plot elements it not only shook things up by bringing a darker more serious tone to the series it also illustrated that while Gilligan is a bumbling goofball he can, in a pinch, prevail against even the most dangerous of foes. The less said the better about the rest of the castaways. As a sitcom adaptation of “The Most Dangerous Game” I’d give “The Hunter” top marks, if only for the brilliant idea of making Gilligan the most ludicrous game.